Whose Image Do You Carry?

By refusing a loaded question, Jesus exposes the real one. It’s not about taxes. It is about allegiance.

The Pharisees come to Jesus with a question that sounds responsible, even thoughtful. It is the kind of question people who take faith seriously are supposed to ask: “Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar, or not?” (v. 17). It sounds like a question about policy, but it’s not. It is a question about loyalty dressed up as a question about law. It is a trap.

The gospel writer lets us in on the setup. This question isn’t to satisfy curiosity; it’s about strategy. The Pharisees and the Herodians (strange bedfellows if there ever were any) find common ground in wanting Jesus gone. He is a disruption to their stability. The plan is simple: force him to pick a side. If he answers yes, he is compromised and his movement loses steam. Another religious voice making peace with the empire. If he answers no, he is a threat. Jesus would then be a problem that Rome would be more than happy to deal with. The Pharisees do not want an answer. They are after an angle.

Like...